FreeCommander Forum

Current Behavior :
When the option "Handle closing as minimization" is set (option checked), both :
1. close via Window X button AND
2. File -> Exit,
result in minimizing FC to system tray.

Desired Behavior :
But the functionality File -> Exit should not behave that way. File -> Exit should always remain as FC close.
That is because, when the Menu Option File -> Exit is chosen, the user has CONSCIOUSLY AND EXPLICITLY chosen to close FC.
So, ONLY the click on X (Window Close) button should be handled handled to Minimize to System Tray.

In Summary :
1. If the above said option is set, clicking on the X (Windows Close) button should cause the utility to be minimized.
2. If the Option is not set the FC should be closed.

However whatever the option is set to, File -> Exit should always close FC.

I have a hard time understanding which option and where

Maybe you could re-write your post?

Forez wrote: 26.07.2022, 22:24 I have a hard time understanding which option and where

Maybe you could re-write your post?

I have re-phrased. Please check.

I concur

Others programs that I use behave in the described desired way: when a user chooses to close them from the main menu, then they ignore the "close = minimization to tray" setting

File menu / Exit or Quit should always close a program regardless of any other options.
All other behaviour is wrong.

horst.epp wrote: 01.08.2022, 18:09 [...]
All other behaviour is wrong.

You mean, you agree with us? Or are you saying that there is something wrong with our FC?

Because if the latter then I did test this option in version 861 32-bit public on Windows 10 Enterprise 20H2 19042.746 x64 and it works as described in the initial post